Small businesses often assume SEO requires expensive software. In reality, a free tool from Google covers the basics, and paid suites only make sense once you're publishing regularly or competing for valuable keywords. This guide compares the most useful options using official product and pricing pages, checked on 19 November 2026. We haven't run our own data-accuracy tests, so we compare published features, limits and prices.
Start free: Google Search Console
Pros
- Free, directly from Google
- Shows the searches that bring people to your site, with clicks, impressions and position
- Submit sitemaps and URLs for crawling; check index coverage
- Email alerts when Google finds issues on your site
Cons
- Only shows data for sites you verify, not competitors
- No keyword research for new topics
Search Console tells you how Google sees your site. According to Google, you can see which queries bring users to your site, analyse impressions, clicks and position, submit sitemaps and individual URLs, review index coverage and get alerted about issues. Every site owner should set it up on day one. (This site publishes a sitemap.xml for exactly this purpose.)
If you use WordPress, a free on-page SEO plugin such as Yoast SEO helps with titles, descriptions and sitemaps. Bluehost, for example, includes the free Yoast SEO plugin on its shared plans; see our Bluehost review.
When to pay, and which tool
Pros
- Free plan: 1 demo project and 10 reports per day
- SEO plan from $139/mo; Starter (SEO + AI search) $199/mo or $165.17/mo annually
- Tracks AI search visibility (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Google)
- Extra toolkits for local, content, social and ads
Cons
- Add-on users from $45/mo
- Specialist toolkits cost extra
- Annual plans paid upfront
Semrush covers keyword research, competitor analysis, rank tracking and site audits, and its newer plans add AI visibility tracking. Starter tracks 500 keywords daily across 5 websites; Pro+ ($299/month, or $248.17/month annually) raises that to 1,500 keywords across 15 websites and adds historical data.
Pros
- Lite from $129/mo; Standard $249/mo; Advanced $449/mo
- Annual billing saves up to 17%
- Lite includes Site Explorer, Site Audit, Rank Tracker, Web Analytics and API/MCP access
- Brand Radar and AI prompt tracking features
Cons
- Lite includes 1 user and 6 months of historical data
- Additional users from $40/mo (Lite)
- Many advanced reports start at Standard
Ahrefs' published pricing shows Lite at $129/month (5 non-verified projects plus unlimited verified projects, 6 months of history, 1 user), Standard at $249/month (2 years of history, 2,000 tracked keywords, Content Explorer and Batch Analysis), and Advanced at $449/month (5 years of history, 5,000 tracked keywords). Prices exclude tax.
A simple monthly SEO routine
- Open Search Console's performance report and note the queries where you get impressions but few clicks.
- Improve the titles and descriptions of those pages so they match what people search for.
- Check the indexing reports for pages Google can't index, and fix any errors.
- Add internal links from your strongest pages to newer ones.
- Only then use a paid tool for new keyword ideas and competitor gaps.
How to choose
- New site, little content: Google Search Console plus a free SEO plugin.
- Publishing weekly and want competitor insight: Semrush SEO/Starter or Ahrefs Lite. Use Semrush's free plan to try before you buy.
- Marketing team doing SEO, content, local and social: Semrush, for its broader toolkit range.
- Managing contacts and email too: pair SEO with a CRM; see our HubSpot review.
Pros and cons
Overall pros
- A free tool (Search Console) covers the essentials
- Paid suites offer deep competitor and keyword data
- Both paid tools offer annual discounts
Overall cons
- Paid SEO suites cost $129+ per month
- Advanced limits and extra users add cost
Who it's for
This guide is for small business owners, bloggers and solo marketers deciding whether to pay for SEO software, and which one to pick.
Pricing at a glance
| Tool | Free option | Entry paid price (monthly billing) | Annual saving |
|---|---|---|---|
| Google Search Console | Free | — | — |
| Semrush | Free plan (10 reports/day) | SEO from $139/mo; Starter $199/mo | Up to 17% |
| Ahrefs | — | Lite $129/mo | Up to 17% |
Prices are in US dollars as shown on official pages on 19 November 2026, before tax. Many reflect limited-time promotions and may differ in your country. Always confirm on the provider's site.
Our verdict
Don't buy an SEO suite before you have content to optimise. Set up Google Search Console now. When you're ready to invest, choose Semrush for the broadest marketing toolkit and AI-search tracking, or Ahrefs Lite if you mainly want backlink and keyword research at a slightly lower entry price.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need to pay for SEO tools?
Not at first. Google Search Console is free and shows how your site performs in Google Search. Paid tools help with competitor and keyword research once you publish regularly.
Semrush or Ahrefs: which is cheaper?
Ahrefs Lite starts at $129/month and Semrush's SEO plan at $139/month, both on monthly billing. Both say annual billing saves up to 17%.
Can I try Semrush for free?
Yes. Semrush has a free plan with 10 reports per day and a 7-day trial on paid plans.
What should I set up first?
Verify your site in Google Search Console and submit your sitemap. Then track which pages and queries get impressions and improve them.
Sources
- Google Search Console
- Semrush subscriptions (knowledge base)
- Semrush Starter vs Pro+ (Semrush blog)
- Ahrefs pricing
- Bluehost web hosting plans (Yoast SEO included)
How we research: we read official pricing pages, plan comparisons, help centres and policies, and cite them above. We don't publish invented test results or ratings. More about our process.